Not signed in (Sign In)


Vanilla 1.1.2 is a product of Lussumo. More Information: Documentation, Community Support.

Welcome Guest!
Want to take part in these discussions? If you have an account, sign in now.
If you don't have an account, apply for one now.
    • CommentAuthormandy
    • CommentTimeJul 14th 2010
     
    Hi
    I have read alot of the other threads recently and I must admit many of the information on there is going over my head.

    I have recently had a bioscreen test done on the bacteria in my stomach.
    The results were disasterous
    E-coli (good bacteria) is suppose to be in the percentage distribution of 70%-90% mine was 1.4 %
    Enterococcus (bad bacteria) suppose to be less the 5% mine 86.4%

    I also had no bifidobacterium it had been completely wiped out

    I was wondering what other peoples thoughts were on these results?
    Has anyone else come across such extreme out of proportion levels?

    Thanks Mandy
    • CommentAuthorlindyd
    • CommentTimeJul 14th 2010
     
    Hi Mandy
    Sounds like you need a very long course of very good probiotics..I would guess if we all had this test done many of us would have similar results..
    Where did you have it done and what did you have to do? Was it actually the bacteria in the stomach or in the bowels ?
    Lindy xx
    • CommentAuthorsylviaann
    • CommentTimeJul 14th 2010
     
    I also recently had a Microbiology profile-Doctors Data (ordered by my doctor). It looks like another piece of my puzzle may be solved.
    The good news: No yeast detected!
    The other news: I have a high level of a specific strain of Dysbiotic Flora present. This may possibly explain my GI symptoms which had worsened a few years ago. Dysbiotic flora is an imbalance or deficiency of beneficial flora and an overgrowth of non-beneficial (imbalance) or even pathogenic microorganisms. It can be due to a number of factors, including consumption of contaminated water or food, daily exposure to chemicals that are toxic to beneficial bacteria, the use of antibiotics, oral contraceptives, or other medications, poor fiber intake, or high stress levels.
    A summary of dysbiotic flora outlined on the test results summary indicated that a number of toxic substances can be produced by dysbiotic flora, including Amines, ammonia, hydrogen sulfide, phenols and secondary bile acids which may cause inflammation or damage to the brush border of the intestinal lining. If left unchecked, long term damage to the intestinal lining may result in leaky gut syndrome, allergies, autoimmune disease, IBS, fatigue, chronic headaches, and sensitivities to a variety of foods!! Gee...this sounds familiar!!!
    There is a recommendation section but I am going to wait to meet with my doctor to discuss our course of action.

    My test also revealed that my beneficial flora is not balanced so I will also wait to discuss how I can find a probiotic with the specific strains mentioned in my test.

    The ironic part is that I just spent a week visiting my sister's family in Virgina. I drank their water all week (They have a reverse osmosis water system and a water softner system) and had absolutely no GI problems. I was elated at the dramatic improvement, which I had not seen in years!! Now that I am back home, I have decided to drink bottled distilled water, until I speak to my doctor. I have a strong suspicion that our water supply contains sulfur and our household water filter is not sufficient. I have been taking epsom salt baths (in Virgina and at home). I am concerned that our bath water also contains sulfur which could possibly cause issues.

    What a puzzle....but at least I am finally piecing it together!
    • CommentAuthorKing
    • CommentTimeJul 14th 2010
     
    I too had bacteria overgrowth in my intestine.

    This was caused by gluten who 'destroy' my intestine because I have Celiac.

    I stopped eating gluten, took some anti-fungal medicin, took probiotics and right now Im taking Colostrum and n-acetyl-glucosamine to repair the damage done.
    • CommentAuthormandy
    • CommentTimeJul 15th 2010
     
    hey sylviaann

    What was the dysbiotic bacteria that was overgrown. Interesting to see if it is the same as mine. There are a number of other bacteria issues that were shown on my report that I did not mention. I am currently on a course of antibiotics to kill of the overgrowth then I am to start taking a dose of e-coli. very exp but hopefully I will show some type of improvements.
    I have always been a bit suspcious of the water in the town I live. Just thinking it may be worth trying some natural spring water for a while see if my last remaining symptoms disappear. I know tap water affects my sisters 11 month old baby...

    hey lindy
    Yeah sorry the test was of the bowels. It was done by a company called bioscreen. You have to send a stool sample away and they basically grow the bacteria for 3 weeks.

    Hey king
    I got tested for celiac and I do not have it but I was basically eating gluten free except for oats. I took them out and I have had some dramatic improvements. Interesting~
  1.  
    Hi sylviaann, I would be interested to know if the tap water where you live is fluoridated. Most water filters are just carbon filters, which don't filter out fluoride, but reverse osmosis filters do remove fluoride. There is also a large overlap in the symptoms of fluoride intolerance and salicylate intolerance, including GI symptoms.

    Hi Mandy, I would also be interested to know if the tap water which affects your sister's baby is fluoridated.

    btw, I have a problem with gluten but have tested negative for coeliac disease. I mentioned on another thread that apparently the majority of people who are gluten sensitive do not have coeliac disease. My understanding is that the defining characteristic of coeliac disease is damage to the microvilli in the intestines, whereas non-coeliac gluten intolerance is a "run-of-the-mill" food intolerance like any other.
    • CommentAuthorsylviaann
    • CommentTimeJul 15th 2010
     
    Hi Mandy,

    The Dysbiotic bacteria that was identified is Citrobacter Freundii complex.

    Black Wizard, thank you for the info. I know that our household water filter is carbon and is only designed to remove chlorine and sediment from our water. Our water is highly chlorinated and it woud not surprise me if it is high in flouride. I called our county water department yesterday to inquire about sulphur levels....our water contains 103 ppm of sulphur and the max acceptable level (MCI) is 250 ppm. I am planning to investigate the floride level next. My mother reminded me that I had serious GI issues as an infant (I was born overseas) and was not able to digest my formula properly. When she switched to using distilled water, my GI problems dissipated.
    • CommentAuthormandy
    • CommentTimeJul 15th 2010
     
    Yes the water that both I and my little nephew drink does have flouride in it. I also believe that the water in my area is slightly high in mercury. Any thoughts on how heavy metals could be affecting us? I only gt sick after moving to this area. I was fine before that.

    Mandy
    • CommentAuthorRita
    • CommentTimeJul 15th 2010
     
    I read a report that said flouride enhances salicyate absorption. Also, chlorine in bath water breaks down to estrogen in the body, which is a phenolic compound.
  2.  
    sylviaann, if you live in America you should be able to find out whether or not your water supply is fluoridated here:

    http://apps.nccd.cdc.gov/MWF/Index.asp

    You probably realise already that distilled water should be low in fluoride.

    Mandy, I have read that babies are particularly vulnerable to fluoride. I don't know a whole lot about heavy metals, but I do know that mercury can cause joint problems, which I suffer from. I had a 24-hour urine test for mercury a few years ago, as recommended by a website I found, but it came back normal, despite the fact that I have 10 mercury amalgam fillings. Two members of my family have had their fillings replaced, and have said they felt better afterwards, but I don't think they had any dramatic health improvement. Reverse osmosis filtered water, rainwater, distilled water, and most spring water should be low in fluoride and heavy metals. Apparently there is a lot of variation in the quality of reverse osmosis filters. As far as I can tell the quality of the reverse osmosis filter I have is good, and I've had a lot of health benefits with it, but for some reason it doesn't seem to allow me to reach a healthy weight. I have only ever been a healthy weight while using unfluoridated tapwater, spring water, or rainwater. I'm back on the rainwater now, so hopefully I'll gain weight again.

    Like you, I've had much better health in some locations than others, and it was only in hindsight that I realised my health was much improved in all the places without fluoridated water supplies. This seems to be a quite common experience. Unfortunately some of the adverse health effects of fluoride can be irreversible. It took me a long time to realise I had a problem with fluoride because I thought it couldn't accumulate in the body like heavy metals. It turns out I was dead wrong.

    Rita, is this the article you are referring to?

    http://www.americanchronicle.com/articles/view/32731

    It was mentioned on this forum a while ago. It says "Fluoride toxicity (yes the stuff in toothpaste and water which is also sold commercially as rat poison) is known to be corrosive to the mucous membranes lining the cut, cause gastro-intestinal inflammation and INCREASE THE EFFECT OF SALICYLATES. Each year children are admitted to hospital emergency departments from fluoride toxicity from eating toothpaste and it is not recommended for infants under 2." Unfortunately the article is not referenced.

    Strictly speaking, chlorine cannot chemically break down to anything because it is an element. I'm sure there's something to what you're saying, though.
  3.  
    I am thinking that based on the fact that your immune system is basically in your gut..or starts there, the condition of your gut dictates how you will respond to different things in water ie; fluoride, chlorine..etc..if you are in a constant state of GI inflammation this might cause a buildup of heavy metals etc to occur..
    It's something I'm trying to figure out as well...repeated exposure to unneeded antibiotics has not helped!
    I've lived in 2 different countries and yes, I've defintetely worsened where I am now...I have brought up this subject before..about being well in one place and sick in another...apparently from what I've read there are many pesticides to be found in drinking water but who knows what really is the truth... you will find differing opinions on whether drinking water from plastic bottles is safe...I wonder myself about exposure to different types of plastic, you can buy special non leeching plastic water bottles but I'm sure there is much debate on that as well..I use a stainless steel bottle myself when I remember to.
    There is so much info to be researched it's really mind boggling but I'm sure that multiple factors have caused my current condition (gluten, fluoride treatments, stress, injury, medications) there are a lot of genetic links too so sorting the enviornmental, genetic and food aspects is a challenge.

    Difference in types of water purification; http://pediatrics.about.com/cs/weeklyquestion/a/080702_ask_3.htm

    Removing fluoride from your water; http://chemistry.about.com/od/chemistryhowtoguide/a/removefluoride.htm
    • CommentAuthorRita
    • CommentTimeJul 16th 2010
     
    Black Wizard. It's been so long, I can't remember if that was the article that I read. I've read it in more than one place, though. Thank you for the correction on chlorine. I actually got that information second hand. I should have said,

    "Some organochlorines are known to be “hormonally active”: they mimic or otherwise disrupt the natural action of the body’s natural sex hormones, including estrogen. Since estrogen is a known risk factor for breast cancer, chemicals that act like estrogen are also likely to increase risk of the disease. Exposures to these chemicals during adulthood may cause estrogen-like effects and promote breast cancer."
  4.  
    Just thought I'd mention that fluoride ions are very small, and are readily absorbed by the skin and lungs.
    • CommentAuthorsylviaann
    • CommentTimeJul 18th 2010
     
    Black Wizard,
    Do you know of any medical research articles referencing the absorption of flouride ions by the skin and lungs? The reason I ask is that for the past few nights, I have been taking an Epsom salts bath at full strenght (2 cups-late evening) as my doctor instructed. The next morning, I have experienced "D". When I was visiting my sister in Virginia last week, I tool the baths every night for five nights with no GI problems.
    I have narrowed my problem to either my bath water or processed sugar. I reintroduced processed sugar (Domino's claims there are no sulfites) a few days ago (added to pancakes) so I am going to stop the sugar for the next several days and see how I respond.

    Anyway, if you know of a medical reference article, I would greatly appreciate it. :)
  5.  
    Risk assessment of chronic poisoning among Indian metallic miners. </pubmed/20386621>
    Dhatrak SV, Nandi SS.
    Indian J Occup Environ Med. 2009 Aug;13(2):60-4

    Fatality due to acute systemic fluoride poisoning following a hydrofluoric acid skin burn. </pubmed/7431138>
    Tepperman PB.
    J Occup Med. 1980 Oct;22(10):691-2

    Fluorine as a factor in premature aging </pubmed/16892576>
    Machoy-Mokrzyńska A.
    Ann Acad Med Stetin. 2004;50 Suppl 1:9-13. Review. Polish.

    sylviaann, here are a few articles I found on PubMed which refer to the absorption of fluoride by the skin or lungs. You might be able to find more there or at www.fluoridealert.org or www.fluorideresearch.org. The terms "fluorine" and "fluoride" are more or less interchangeable, since fluorine is so reactive that it invariably exists in nature as fluoride. I'm not aware of any studies specifically relating to skin absorption of fluoride in fluoridated water. Presumably there are ethical problems with selecting people on the basis that they are likely to react adversely to a known toxin, and selecting people randomly would probably mean a large trial would be required to find anything statistically significant.
    My understanding is that it is universally agreed that fluoride is absorbed by the skin and lungs, but nobody really knows how fast it is absorbed by the skin. However, consider that salicylates are readily absorbed by the skin, and that the molecular weight of salicylic acid is 138.1, while the atomic weight of fluorine is only 19.
    GI symptoms and hives are 2 of the most common effects of fluoride, and it wouldn't surprise me if it caused your reaction. On the other hand, it's possible that the GI problems were due to the magnesium in the Epsom salts, and that it took a while for it to build up in your body - 2 cups is a lot of Epsom salts. Did your doctor to tell you how long to bathe for? The longer the time, the greater the amount of magnesium, sulphate, and fluoride you will absorb.
    Have you considered applying a skin cream, or diluted glycerol/glycerin, with Epsom salts dissolved in it? As far as I'm aware, the Epsom salts should be completely absorbed this way, so you get a controlled dose without waste, and the absorption of fluoride, chlorine, etc should be low. I know that some glycerin is derived from plants, but you can get glycerin that comes from animal fat. I realise that doing things this way isn't for everyone, but I'd be interested if anyone else has tried it. If you do try it, make sure you work out an appropriate dose - like other minerals, magnesium can be toxic.
    All the best, and let me know how you go.:)
    • CommentAuthorsylviaann
    • CommentTimeJul 19th 2010
     
    Thank you for the reference articles Black Wizard. My doctor( a peds holistic physician) instructed me to use 2 cups of epsom salts (he considers this to be full strength) every night. He uses this protocol frequently with his autistic patients (the majority of his peds patients are autistic) ad it usually helps with sleeping and the PST issues. I take a fifteen minute bath up the neck in water as warm as I can tolerate. When I started using the salts three weeks ago, I gradually introduced them and slowly increased my dose until I reached the 2 cup strength approx ten days ago. Since I noticed GI symptoms two days ago, I stopped processed sugar again (this morning) and have not experienced any GI symptoms. I also reduced my epsom salts to 1.5 cups last night, just in case .

    I have a feeling the problem is the processed sugar since I had no problems with the epsom salts last week....unless it is my bath water.

    I have not been able to find animal based glycerin. If you know where I can find it in the US, please let me know. I reacted severely to vegetble glycerin a few months ago (severe myoclonus). Is there a specific cream you have used with the epsom salts mixed in or did you make your own with the animal based glycerin?
    I know that I read an article on my physician's website that outlines the procedure for using/applying an epsom salt Rub using the salts and water.

    Many thanks again for your ideas,
    Sylvia :)
  6.  
    You're welcome, Sylvia. I should have mentioned before that magnesium has a protective effect against fluoride, because there is a strong tendency for magnesium fluoride (MgF2) to form, which is water insoluble and cannot be absorbed by the body (and similarly with calcium and calcium fluoride). I haven't found any good quantitative information about this, but my feeling is that the amount of Epsom salts you are using would have a significant protective effect. Taking magnesium by any method will help, but absorbing fluoride and then taking magnesium is not as good as not absorbing the fluoride in the 1st place. You could try baths without the Epsom salts and see what happens, although taking fluoride tablets would be the most direct way to work out what short-term effect fluoride has on you.

    It's hard to know how much Epsom salts is too much. I have read that the maximum daily intake of magnesium as a supplement is 350 mg, but that still leaves the question of how quickly the skin absorbs it from water. As for sugar, I'm sure you know more about that than I do. You seem to have a good idea of what may have caused your reaction, so I'm sure you'll work it out soon.

    I've just used animal-based glycerin which I diluted with water. The brand is Faulding, made by the company Symbion. I called their consumer line, and was told it is made from cow fat, and doesn't have any preservatives added. I suppose it probably isn't available in the US, and for some reason that particular product is not listed on their website. Maybe you can find a way to get it with a tolerable delivery charge. There is also a product called aqueous cream which might be OK, but I don't know about its availability in America. You'd have to think something would be available in the US. Maybe contacting a bunch of pharmaceutical and chemical supply companies would yield results.

    I actually get myoclonus as well. I didn't know what it was until I read one of your posts a little while ago and looked it up, so thanks for that. Mine is not severe - just a "hypnic jerk" every time I was on the verge of falling asleep for several years, but it did make it very hard to fall asleep at times. I haven't noticed it so much lately. My salicylate intolerant grandmother has the same thing.
    • CommentAuthorsylviaann
    • CommentTimeJul 20th 2010
     
    Hi Black Wizards,

    My myoclonus symptoms started almost four years ago and also occurs at sleep onset (day or night). It was so severe (prior to diagnosis) that I would be up all night. Thankfully, it has improved during the past year but I still take a small dose of clonazapam at bedtime to help me get past the twitches and jerks. However, whenever I ingest food, inhale an offending chemical or spice, or apply a lotion or cosmetic item containing benzoates, sulfites or preservatives, my symptoms are severe.

    Do you have trouble with sulfites and preservatives?
    How long have you suffered with sals intolerance?
    Do you have to adhere to the neglible-low sals category or are tyou able to eat foods in the moderate category?
    Interesting that your grandmother had the same symptoms! Does she have trouble sleeping too?
  7.  
    Hi Sylvia,
    I'm really not sure about sulfites and preservatives. The most obvious reaction I get is hives, but they are triggered by heat, and it's winter here. I'm planning to do the elimination diet when it warms up again. I also only eat whole foods, mostly organic. A few years ago I was eating rainbow trout, which is an oily freshwater fish, and noticed it gave me hives. That could have been from preservative, or possibly from histamine in the fish oil.

    I'm not entirely sure how long I have suffered with salicylate intolerance, either. I suspect I was either born with it, or developed it in childhood. The very 1st intolerance reaction I noticed was to honey, in late childhood. I know I'm not fructose intolerant, because I've been hydrogen breath tested for it and also don't react to pears, and I don't have hayfever, so it wasn't pollen in the honey. I'm pretty sure that mint flavoured lifesavers and toothpaste burnt my mouth earlier than that, but I thought that was normal. I can't remember when the myoclonus started, but I think it was in my 20s.

    I have been eating some food in the low and moderate salicylate categories, but with a heavy bias toward the negligible category. I have actually eaten organic strawberries and apricots in the past with no obvious reaction, even though non-organic strawberries and apricots gave me bad diarrhoea every time I ate them. This made me think it was just pesticide which was the problem, but now I know that pesticides can make salicylate intolerance worse. I could go on, it's all very complicated, but I'm fairly confident that most of the pieces of my health puzzle are now in place.

    Well, it's not just my grandmother! I haven't quizzed everybody about their symptoms, but it is looking more and more likely that all of my grandmother's 3 children are salicylate intolerant, I strongly suspect my 2 siblings are as well, and it seems quite likely that my dad and his mother also fit the bill, meaning that I have it coming to me from both sides of the family. And yes, my maternal grandmother does have trouble sleeping, but she's 87, and I think this is very common at that age. She had quite bad mouth ulcers and a sore tongue, and lots of hives and itchy skin, but these have all cleared up since reducing her salicylate intake a couple of months ago. She still has severe rheumatoid arthritis, though.

    You mentioned sulfur in your tap water before. I don't know how you can find out what form the sulfur is in, but obviously if it were in the form of sulfate it wouldn't be a problem.

    If Mandy is reading this, she may be interested to know that a study found that fluoride greatly increases the rate of absorption of lead in rats. Maybe it is the same with humans, and with other heavy metals.
    • CommentAuthorkelza
    • CommentTimeJul 21st 2010
     
    mandy I had the same test, and i have a problem with gluten/wheat/gluten free oats.... very interesting! my dietician ordered the test but my doctor didnt want anything to do with the results. My dietician referred me to my doc haha so i didnt get anywhere with it

    E-coli count 33.3%
    Total Strep count 66.7% should be <3%
    Total Bacteroides 64% should be 90-95%
    Prevotella spp 36% should be <10%
    Bifidobacterium 0% should be 5-11%
    Lactobaccillus 0% should be 0.5-1.5%

    There are a heap of other things that should have a reading that were 0% but the above are the ones the dietician was paying attention to.

    If anyone knows what it means etc I would really appreciate your comments, in as layman terms as possible :)
  8.  
    Kelza..were you taking antibiotics in the past? what about antacids or things like priolisec (proton pump inhibitiors) for heartburn? These can all cause disbalance in good bacteria in your system..seems easy to do but not so easy to correct. since I have been prescribed too many antibiotics in the past I am suspicious that I have a similar problem..i have been eating natural yogurt which seems to be helping but may need additional help with antifungals/antibiotics to kill off bad bacteria..
    Sounds like you might need a new DR!

    I also tested severely deficient in vitamin D..so much that I was put on a prescription..50,000 units every 3 days.
    I have not done the yeast/bacterial test..that's next on my list
    • CommentAuthorRita
    • CommentTimeJul 21st 2010
     
    Vitamin D is a fat soluable vitamin, and don't we need the omega 3 to absorb them? That would all fit in with the fish oil theory.
    • CommentAuthormandy
    • CommentTimeJul 22nd 2010
     
    Hey Kelza

    Seems like your results are very similar to mine. Where are you located? Im was first seeing a dodgy doctor. I think now I have found a good understanding one. He is in Melbourne.. I went on a dose of antibiotics to kill off the bad bacteria. I am now on a dose of e.coli... expensive but hoping that it helps. No one can give me the answers of if it is causing any of my sals, amines and all the other issues I have.

    Does anyone know if fish oil has amines in it?
    • CommentAuthormarieling
    • CommentTimeJul 22nd 2010
     
    Hi Mandy
    I don't think anyone has tested fish oil for amines, but a common finding from people intolerant to amines is that fish oil is not able to be taken - I am one of them, and I've tried 3 times with 3 different brands.
    Kind Regards
    Marie
  9.  
    Mandy, there is some information on fish oil on the fedupwithfoodadditives website. Unfortunately the answers to a lot of health questions can only be gained through personal trial and error, or at least that has been my experience. I wouldn't doubt that antibiotics can contribute to intolerances, but whether they can actually cause salicylate intolerance is another question. My grandmother says that she got hives from eating oranges as a child, and I don't think antibiotics had been invented then. She grew up on an orchard.
    If you're living in Melbourne, I would be particularly wary of fluoride in the water there. The level of fluoride is one part per million, which is the equal highest in Australia (Perth and Adelaide are at 0.8 ppm, for example), but possibly more important is the fact that Melbourne's tap water is unusually soft, meaning it is very low in calcium and magnesium. I developed the joint problems I have now while living in Melbourne, and a study was done by a dentistry lecturer at Melbourne University which showed that RSI could be "incipient skeletal fluorosis". Sorry to keep banging on about fluoride, I just thought it was particularly relevant in this case. The test I had for mercury, which I mentioned earlier, was done while living in Melbourne, having been there 4 or 5 years.
    • CommentAuthorsylviaann
    • CommentTimeJul 23rd 2010
     
    Greetings Black Wizards,

    Well..I am starting to become highly suspicious that flouride might be part of my problem. I found it interesting that fluoride found in our water can cause GI problems, seizures, weight loss, blurry vision. The symptoms are similar to my salicylate intolerant symptoms. I also found it ironic that when I returned from my eleven day trip, I noticed that some of my chemical sensitivities had dimished (not sure if the epsom salt baths or the reverse osmosis water were contributing factors in this improvement). I stopped processed sugar a few days ago and took another epsom salt bath (1.5 cups of salts). I seemed to be fine the next morning. Two nights ago, I repeated the epsom salts bath (late evening) and the next morning, I seemed to have a laxative affect from something (possibly the magnesium in the salts??). My doctor had avised me that epsom salts should not cause a laxative affect when using them as a soaking agent so I am perplexed. I used 2 cups of salts nightly for 5-6 nights when I was in Virginia and had no problems. My sister has a soft water system for bathing and the reverse osmosis system for drinking water. This is why I wonder if I am reacting to our bath water and not the salts??
    I read several articles about flouride sensitivity and allergy symptoms so it makes sense to me. I am so anxious to meet with my holistic peds physician because he believes in water systems for patients with compromised immune systems.

    I did not take a bath last night and was unable to sleep for most of the night. I am so frustrated but ready for some answers.
    How long did it take you to assemble your puzzle?
    • CommentAuthorsylviaann
    • CommentTimeJul 23rd 2010
     
    BTW, according to my county's water report from 2009, our area's water flouride level is .608. The EPA's threshold (allowable limit) is 4 MCL.
  10.  
    Hi Sylvia,
    It sounds like you have a real dilemma. There is some information on Epsom salt baths here:

    http://www.epsomsaltcouncil.org/articles/Report_on_Absorption_of_magnesium_sulfate.pdf

    Epsom salts and other magnesium compounds are used as laxatives. When your doctor says that Epsom salts should not cause a laxative effect when using them as a soaking agent, it is not quite the same thing as saying that this cannot happen. The report above concludes that Epsom salt baths are safe, but also notes large variation in the effect on different people, and suggests taking them 2 or 3 times a week. I had a laxative effect just from soaking my hands for about 20 minutes, using 3 slightly heaped teaspoons (maybe 6 teaspoons worth) of Epsom salts and a bowl just big enough to fit my hands into, but it only happened after about 4 days of doing this. lindyd has reported a similar experience.
    I'm not sure what "MCL" stands for, but the fluoride levels of 0.608 and 4 which you quote are almost certainly in parts per million, or equivalently milligrams per litre or milligrams per kilogram. A level of 0.608 ppm is not incredibly high, but high enough to potentially cause problems. Although fluoride is toxic for everyone, the phenomenon of fluoride sensitivity has been identified (as you have discovered), and it seems likely that those who are salicylate sensitive are more likely to be fluoride sensitive than others. Exactly what do you mean when you say that your sister has a "soft water system"?
    I can think of 3 possible solutions: either you get your Epsom salts by other means, you get sulfate by other means, or you get the enzymes you need to break down Phenols by other means. If there is no animal derived glycerin in the US, you could soak a smaller portion of your body, such as your hands, in an amount of water small enough to use distilled water or some other water which is low in fluoride. The smaller surface area of skin under the water can be counteracted by a higher concentration of Epsom salts, which just means more Epsom salts per unit of water, and may actually require less than the 1.5 cups you have been using. Another option is to dissolve the Epsom salts in low fluoride water and drink it. I have been using one 8th of a teaspoon of Epsom salt crystals in 1 cup of water, but maybe you would need more than that. I have read that sulphate is not absorbed as well when ingested, but it might be worth a try anyway. My RPAH Handbook says that ointments do not contain preservatives, so possibly that is an alternative to glycerin.
    As for getting sulphate by other means, I think that Kirkman labs' Phenol Assist Companion is designed for that purpose. Have you tried it? Maybe another supplement discussed by Pierre and others would also help in this regard.
    Phenol Assist and No Fenol are used to break down Phenols, and I think there are a few other products you can use for this. I'm sure there are others on the forum who know more about it than I do, but I do know that Kirkman labs is based in Portland, Oregon, which has an unfluoridated water supply, and as far as I know they manufacture supplements there.
    I can hardly bear to think about how long it has taken me to work out what I know now, and I've still got a fair way to go. Let's just say I kept a food diary in 2002. I've seen many doctors, including specialists who should have been able to work out I had salicylate intolerance, but no such luck. Having serious joint problems doesn't help when it comes to research, either. I hope you will be luckier than I have been so far.
    • CommentAuthorsylviaann
    • CommentTimeJul 24th 2010
     
    Hi Black Wizard,

    Sounds like you and I are similar in our discoveries. I saw 15 doctors before I decided to start a detailed food, med and exposure diary last summer. The diary is what led me to discover my sals and sulfite issues.

    I take Carbgest enzymes (Enzymedica brand) for sals and phenol digestion. I tried taking Phenol Assist companion with Carbgest but I stopped after several days because of a possible reaction to it.
    As far as the Epsom salts, I will definitely try soaking my hands or feet in half-whole cup using purified water. I cannot drink it as I am very sensitive to oral magnesium.

    I was researching Fluoride yesterday and came across a non-profit organization here in the US who has conducted research on the toxicity of Fluoridaton. I received a call this evening from the Executive Director (Deb Moore PhD) of this organization called “Second Look”.
    http://www.slweb.org/
    This is the only organization in the US that has a Fluoride Toxicity Research Collaborative. Dr. Russell Blaylock, a well-respected retired neurosurgeon who has written numerous books, is on the Research staff. http://www.slweb.org/ftrc.html

    Anyway, she and I spoke for about ten minutes and she believes that I have been suffering from fluoride toxicity or sensitivity . She said that Florida (my state) is the worst state for having high levels of fluoride in the water. She is going to call me back next week so we can speak at length and I am hoping to get my doctor's input on what he thinks when we meet within the next few weeks. Deb encouraged me to take sponge baths (sponge off or use cool water and take the shower quickly). She said that Fluoride is absorbed by the skin and the hot water vapors. This may explain some of my reactions after taking baths since I have returned to Florida. No baths allowed unless the water is Unflouridated. She also said fluoride is found in many prescriptions and she would review this with me. She said it is imperative that I remove all fluoride from my diet (foods too), supplements and Prescriptions immediately.
    I take Kirkman Lab products, including Calcium powder, Vitamin D, and probiotics. I just hope that the calcium powder and my Carbgest enzymes are free of fluoride!!

    This puzzle is more perplexing by the day..I wonder if Leaky gut (the dysbiotic bacteria I acquired) caused this fluoride sensitivity or toxicity..or if my immune system is unable to tolerate it. At this point, I just need to remove it from my environment and from what Dem told me, it is not going to be easy.
    BTW, my sister's soft water system is for household water and I am not certain if it removes Fluoride. I am planning to call her to investigate. She has a separate reverse osmosis system for drinking water.

    Do you have unfluoridated water for bathing and drinking?
  11.  
    I think my vitamin D deficiency is caused by being ill and spending all my time indoors..also my mom had skin cancer so made me afraid to be in the sun..I cannot tolerate the heat...it is much more humid and hotter for longer here than what I am used to. I also was avoiding milk. My one sister who lives in Alberta also reported that she had a vitamin D deficiency.
    Where we both grew up has hard water and natural molybdenum and copper as there is a moly/copper mine that closed a few years ago. The city sits in the cascade mountains at a higher elevation and might possibly have higher levels of other minerals as well, I haven't researched it.

    The vitamin D suppliment I am taking I noticed is also used for hypoparathyroidism as well...i am noticing some marked improvement in my overall energy levels.

    I do think that the worsening of my condition was quite noticeably timed with the fact that I got fluoride varnish put on my teeth...I got really tired of getting cavity after cavity but thinking back I think it was actually celiac and malabsorption of calcium weakening my teeth and causing cracks because I haven't had any new cavities since discovering that I am celiac. Well...also vit D is important for absorption of calcium, magnesium, potassium and so on...

    My other sister lived in New Zealand for 8 years and also developed multiple problems related to food/absorption and though I'm not sure I think she had some bacterial overgrowth..I don't talk to her much.

    Facinating!
  12.  
    Sylvia and lizzbethsue, I've responded to your posts on a new thread called "fluoride and other inorganic toxins" so that I leave some room for those who want to discuss bacteria overgrowth.
    • CommentAuthorlizzbethsue
    • CommentTimeJul 29th 2010 edited
     
    Well I was reading a website the other day another one on leaky gut and I think I do know how this has happened to me, I saw "contaminated drinks" and rememberd an incident a couple of years ago...I went to a restaurant/bar and had a couple of drinks as did my husband..we both had to stop on the way home and vomit which was really strange because I only had 2 drinks and his were non-alcoholic..I looked this restaurant up and saw they were written up by the county health dept for "unsanitary conditions" and am convinced it was something in the ice..the time period fits with my major health decline and malayse and my food sensitivies and since at that time I had no idea I was celiac I was still eating gluten. I was sick with some sort of "flu" for about a month afterwards...have not confirmed bacterial overgrowth but am pretty sure this is the likely cause. About all of the symptoms of "leaky gut" or "increased intestinal permability" are the same...including food intolerance and bacterial overgrowth caused by NSAID's, hormonal birth control, antibiotic use etc..
    This happened in Oct '08 and I lost 70lbs from Feb '09 to Sept 09' and started having really bad "hot flashes" that winter so it really fits..

    http://www.crohns.net/Miva/education/leakygut.shtml
    What is Leaky Gut Syndrome?
    Leaky Gut Syndrome (intestinal permeability) is not a disease but rather an intestinal dysfunction that underlies many different illnesses and symptoms. However, Leaky gut syndrome is actually poorly recognized but yet an extremely common problem.

    What causes Leaky Gut Syndrome?
    Leaky gut syndrome results in an increase in the so-called permeability of the mucosal intestinal lining to luminal macro molecules. In other words, large spaces develop between the cells of the gut wall and this allows bacteria, toxins and food to leak in.


    What happens next with Leaky Gut Syndrome?
    Once the lining of the digestive tract becomes inflamed or damaged it disrupts the way the digestive system functions. The spaces that open up allow large food antigens to be absorbed into the body, which are regarded as 'foreign' to the body's defense system. This results in the production of antibodies against what was once harmless and innocuous foods. This is how food allergies are created as well as new symptoms with target organs. e.g. arthritis and fibromyalgia.

    Avoid Unhealthy Food if you have Leaky Gut Syndrome
    Poor food choices not only cause Leaky Gut Syndrome but may lead to food sensitivities as well. Processed foods are low in nutrients and fiber and often contain lots of food additives, unhealthy fats and sugar. This creates an alkaline intestinal pH and a slow waste transit time.

    Symptoms of the Inflamed Gut associated with Leaky Gut Syndrome
    It does not absorb nutrients and foods properly so it may result in fatigue and bloating.
    When the detoxification pathways that line the gut are compromised, chemical sensitivity may also occur.
    The leaking of toxins also burdens the liver so that the body is less able to handle everyday chemicals.
    Carrier proteins are also damaged so nutrient deficiencies occur which cause a variety of symptoms:
    Magnesium deficiency causes muscle spasms and fibromyalgia
    Copper deficiency leads to high cholesterol and Osteoarthritis
    Zinc deficiency leads to malabsorption which causes hair loss and some eye disorders (macular degeneration)
    Inflamed Gut Lining because of Leaky Gut Syndrome
    When the gut lining is inflamed the protective coating of lgA (immunoglobulin A) is negatively affected. The body is unable to ward off bacteria, viruses and parasites as well as fungus and yeasts like Candida. These pathogenic bad organisms then pass from the gut cavity into the bloodstream and set up infection anywhere else in the body.

    Formation of Antibodies with Leaky Gut Syndrome
    Formation of antibodies may occur. They leak across and look similar to antigens on our own tissues. So when an antibody is made to attack it, it also attacks the tissue. This is possibly how auto-immune and chronic disease like Crohns Disease, Rheumatoid arthritis, Lupus, Multiple Sclerosis, and Thyroiditis start.

    Formation of Toxins with Leaky Gut Syndrome
    Together these conditions encourage the formation of toxins. These toxins can also cause leaks. When food particles escape through the leaks into the blood stream, the immune system senses them as a threat (an antigen), and results in food sensitivities.

    Leaky Gut Syndrome may cause confusion, memory loss, and 'brain fog'
    In addition to the creation of food allergies, the bloodstream is flooded by bacteria, fungi and parasites that, in the healthy state, would not be able to penetrate the protective barrier of the gut. These microbes and their toxins, if present in large enough amounts, can overwhelm the liver's ability to detoxify. This results in symptoms such as confusion, memory loss, and 'brain fog'.

    The following may lead to Leaky Gut Syndrome (Intestinal Permeability):
    Antibiotics - because they lead to the overgrowth of abnoraml flora in the gastrointestinal tract (bacteria, parasites, candida, fungi)

    Alcohol and caffeine (strong gut irritants)
    Foods and beverages contaminated by parasites like Giardia lamblia, cryptosporidium, blastocystis hominis and others
    Foods and beverages contaminated by bacteria like helicobacter pylori, klebsiella, citrobacter, pseudomonas and others
    Chemicals in fermented and processed food (dyes, preservatives, peroxidized fats)
    Enzyme deficiencies (e.g. celiac disease, lactase deficiency causing lactose intolerance)
    NSAIDS (non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs) like ASA, ibuprofen, indomethacin, etc.
    Prescription corticosteroids (e.g. prednisone, hydrocortisone, DepoMedrol, etc.)
    High refined carbohydrate diet (e.g. candy bars, cookies, cake, soft drinks, white bread)
    Prescription hormones like the birth control pill
    Mold and fungal mycotoxins in stored grains, fruit and refined carbohydrates
    Dysbiosis and Gastrointestinal Disease
    Chemo-therapy and radiation therapy causing immune overload
    • CommentAuthornanciswell
    • CommentTimeJul 31st 2010
     
    Sylvia..

    I was not sure from your post about the affects of epsom salts/? Is it that you are getting loose bowels only./?

    I am taking a magnesium oil product made from sea salt.. Being super sensitive it is the first magnesium I have found that does not make me ill. I find with this my bowels do loosen up,, so yes putting something on your skin can affect your bowel habits.\

    I just posted on another thread and will mention it again.. Putting something on our skin can cause just as much a problem with reactions as it does go right through to our livers / etc.. I had a terrible time with a cream which had propylene glycol in it.. My liver was bothering me terribly and I got very constipated..

    Recently I am having problems with epsom salts.. It helps me with bad pain in my lower abdomen. By just putting epsom salts on my skin I am reacting badly. It goes right to my digestive system.. How that happens I have no idea.. I will get the burps/ irritable bowel problems by putting it on my skin??

    Even me who has been through the mill of being different can hardly beleive this one.!!!!.
    • CommentAuthornanciswell
    • CommentTimeJul 31st 2010
     
    Reposting this from another thread.. .. I

    I may well have found why I am now sensitive to epsom salts.

    Epsom salts are high in oxalates.. Well I have been drinking a fair amount of celery and parsley juice from my garden.. figuring I would get more nourishment , BUT parsley and celery are high in oxalates..

    SO I figure I have reached my limit of oxalates now.. and will surely not be drinking much juice from now on.

    IT is said that to decrease the amount of oxalate buildup to take magnesium.. Fortunately I so far tolerate magnesium oil made from sea salt..

    http://www.mothering.com/discussions/showthread.php?t=1190515
    • CommentAuthormarieling
    • CommentTimeJul 31st 2010
     
    Dear Nanciswell
    Did you also realise that according to the new RPAH handbook parsely is in the HIGH category for salicylates? It is apparently still OK to use in small amounts as a condiment, but generous use (as I would imagine juicing it is) would be very likely to cause problems.
    Kind Regards
    Marie
  13.  
    Curious as to Kelza and Mandy's bacteria treatment....anything new?
  14.  
    The conventional usage of the term "Epsom salts" instead of "Epsom salt" is a misnomer, because it is just one salt, namely magnesium sulphate (MgSO4). Oxalic acid is C2H2O4, so there are no oxalates in Epsom salts.
  15.  
    THanks Black.
    I wondered about the oxalates in epsom salts.. I ate some celery , apparently high in oxalates and phew I did not react.. Celery is now my only vegi as parsley is apparently high in sals.. I will try parsley tomorrow..

    And now I wonder what it is I am reacting to with the epsom salts.???

    I went searching for an alternative source of sulfate as that helps with my severe pain.. Has anyone ever tried glauber salts.. another natural salt called sodium sulfate.. I am wondering if I put this on my skin would that replace the sulfate in the epsom??

    nanci
  16.  
    I have been searching and think I understand the epsom salt/ oxalate connection.. It is not that the epsom salts have oxalates in them .. it is that the body will have problems/ detox when a person has high oxalates and also takes epsom salts..

    http://www.mothering.com/discussions/showthread.php?p=9813574&highlight=epsom+salts+oxalate#post9813574

    So I am wondering that my oxalate level has been rising as the only vegis i have been eating are celery and parsley for a few months now./?? I used to only notice good affects from epsom .. now I get my regular bad reaction within minutes..
    • CommentAuthorlindyd
    • CommentTimeAug 2nd 2010
     
    Hi Nanci
    Have you tried glucosamine sulphate? I didn't realise how much better I was feeling until I ran out and didn't take any for a few days and started to feel the way I used to feel..
    I now take 2000mg a day (equivalent to 1500mg absorption).
    Lindy xx
    • CommentAuthormandy
    • CommentTimeAug 3rd 2010
     
    Hi lizbethsue

    I have had a dose of antibiotics and am currently on e-coli tablets and some symbiotic which is a general gut flora. I have also started taking a basic enzyme with every meal as well as a combination of potassium bi-carb and sodium bi carb.

    I am basically symptom free at the moment. I have also gone off tap water to spring water also. I am still on a very very restricted diet. I am not sure how I will go when I try reintroduce some food. I do know that a tablet I took the other day had 1mg of pepermint oil in it and it made me really sick so there has been no mircales as yet.

    I do know that the stomach cramps I use to get after each meal has gone and that I dont have to get up and run to the toilet every morning now. My urine PH has also returned to nornal it use to be very acidic.

    I plan to keep this up for a little bit longer and try and reintroduce some foods slowly.

    Mandy
    • CommentAuthorsylviaann
    • CommentTimeAug 3rd 2010
     
    Hi Mandy,

    I am curious to know what type of bacteria your doctor found? My peds specialist found Citrobacter Freundii cpmplex through my microbiology test.
    What type of antibiotic did you take?
    Based on my situation/bacteria, my doctor has instructed me to take mega doses of a Kirkman Lab Lactobacillius for six weeks and he will re-test me at that point. There is also an all natural herb he had advised me to take called Uva Ursi (supposed to be extremely effective to eradicate Citrobacter Freundii). However, it is derived from berries so we decided to wait on that. If my bacteria does not clear up in six weeks, I will probably have to take an antibiotic. We are trying to avoid inflicting anymore GI/Flora damage with an antibiotic, unless absolutely necessary.
    I am also still taking Carbgest digestive enzymes.
    Please let me know what happens when you re-introduce foods as I am in a similar situation. My doctor is hopeful that I have a severe case of Leaky Gut and that my food and chemical intolerances are most likely due to the bacteria and leaky gut.
    I would love to know how long I have been walking around with the gut bacteria.....my guess is years.

    Sylvia :)
  17.  
    Hi Nanci,
    the most obvious cause of the symptom you describe from Epsom salts is too much magnesium. You could certainly get sulphate from sodium sulphate, except that you might get too much sodium, and since it is Na2SO4 there are 2 sodium ions per sulphate ion, whereas magnesium sulphate has one magnesium ion per sulphate ion. A mixture of magnesium sulphate and sodium sulphate might work best, but it's probably something you should talk to a doctor about if you're planning to do it long term.

    I would be interested to know if you, or anyone else, has been tested for Oxalobacter, which are the bacteria which break down oxalates.
    • CommentAuthorlizzbethsue
    • CommentTimeAug 3rd 2010 edited
     
    Thanks Mandy..Dr I went to says I am probably dealing with same issue as Sylvia..leaky gut..probably have been walking around with it for years myself, just haven't figured out what bacteria I have % of good/bad...
    Interesting about oxalobacter black wizards...I will have to look into that has well since I seem to have issues with oxalates...looks like it is not something normally tested for..
    • CommentAuthorsylviaann
    • CommentTimeAug 4th 2010
     
    I posted this under another thread but meant to place it here.....

    I forgot to mention that my recent Microbiology test also revealed Klebsiella bacteria (in addition to Citrobacter Freundii) and my Organic Acids test uncovered Clostridia bacteria (which was also found in the microbiology test).
    • CommentAuthorlindyd
    • CommentTimeAug 4th 2010
     
    Hi Sylvia
    Did your reports suggest that there were "overgrowths" of certain bacteria? It is "normal" for healthy individuals to have a certain amount of "bad" bacteria in their gut, just as it is "normal" to have a certain level of candida and other yeasts.
    In a healthy person colonies of these "bad" organisms are kept under control by the immune system and the "good" organisms we also have in our bodies.
    However when the immune system is low, during illness, stress, after antibiotics etc, the "bad" organisms may have a chance to multiply. It is an overgrowth that is an issue not the presence of the bacteria.
    It's good that you are being advised to take high levels of probiotics..although I would have suggested a wide spectrum one..
    If you do take the anitbiotics then a long dose of wide spectrum probiotics is essential as the antibiotic will kill off all of your good bacteria as well as the bad.. you need to replenish all of the different kinds... not just one..
    Lindy xx
    • CommentAuthorsylviaann
    • CommentTimeAug 5th 2010
     
    Hi Lindy!

    My peds integrative physisician is using the Lactobacillius Duo (Kirkman's) for six weeks to specifically eradicate my Citrobacter Freundii complex bacteria ( this is Dysbiotic bacteria). I will be taking four capsules per day (I am slowing titrating up). Sometimes this therapy will work but if not, we may have to go to anitibiotics (last resort). We are trying to avoid antibiotics due to my GI history and of course, they will destroy the good bacteria in my gut if taken.

    My Microbiology Lab results outline Beneficial Bacteria in the gut and their growth status (i.e. NG , 2+, etc). 3+ or more in this category is considered good. I had mainly NG and two categories with a 2+ reading. The Imbalanced flora catagory does not really affect a person but is listed. The dysbiotic category is of real concern.

    My Organic Acids test pinointed the Clostridia bacteria and the probiotIcs I am taking are my doctors therapy (first choice). He also suggested trying Uva Ursi to eradicate the Citrobacter Freundii but I advised him that it is derived from a berry and I dd not feel comfortable right now trying it. He is very understanding and so we will stick with the Lactobacillius Duo for six weeks and get retested. He also advised me that yeast may possibly "pop up" on the Organics Acid re-test because when you restore the flora, sometimes this can occur.
    I have confidence in this doctor..he is extremely sharp and open to ideas. If we can eradicate this bacteria, I am thinking he may switch me back to the probiotic I had previously been taking (Kirkman's Inulin free- which contained several different strains).

    Hugs,
    Sylvia XXX000
  18.  
    It says here

    http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/444683-treatment

    that "Fluoroquinolones, cephalosporins, tetracyclines, and macrolide preparations are particularly toxic to Oxalobacter bacteria, while penicillin and sulfa drugs have relatively little effect."
    Maybe the effect of antibiotics on other bacteria also varies.
  19.  
    Thanks Marie.. I have stopped the parsley and doing alot better.. Kind of annoying the content has now been changed.. That leaves me with celery as my only vegi.. and not any that I am aware of to try..

    Can you tell me about that RPHA booklet../ I do not have one.

    I have tried the glucosamine sulfate and react probably due to amines. I decided against the sodium sulfate as the reaction would have been the same.

    It was not the magnesium as I have been taking more of the magnesium oil this week and there was a definite link to the oxalates and sulfate.
    I stopped the juicing of the celery and parsley only a week ago.. And for the past two days am back to doing fine with the epsom salts.!!!.

    So I was having my regular what I call salicylate reaction with taking the epsom salts on my skin during that time my liver was taxed with the higher amount of oxalates I was consuming with the juicing.... The way it maybe works is that with the build up of oxalates the liver is more compromised and cannot deal with the detox that happens ..

    I have beem saved again due to people like you all who are sharing their journey.. thanks to all.. Peace and best wishes.

    nanci
    • CommentAuthormarieling
    • CommentTimeAug 5th 2010
     
    Hi Nanci
    Glad to hear you are feeling better again.
    The RPAH book is available from the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital Allergy Unit www.sswahs.nsw.gov.au/rpa/allergy This book is co-authored by Anne Swain and includes recent research that has seen some changes to how some foods are classified (i.e some foods that were thought to be low in sals have been moved to the moderate or high lists and others have moved down a list). Unless someone knows of some overseas research that has been done in the last few years it is the most up to date research available on Australian foods. This book also contains information on shopping, meal planning, supplements, environmental factors and balancing your diet. There are recipes and heaps of tips - it is basically worth every cent you pay for it, even if you find that some of the foods don't quite match up to what you can eat/buy overseas

    The book also lists amines, glutamates and has sections for food additives, gluten, soy and dairy. I would highly recommend people who don't get to a point of being basically symptom free on a low sals diet to use this guide and do the proper elimination diet with challenges on the above. This is because it is common for people to be intolerant to more than just sals - especially if you have multiple or debilitating symptoms. And as Blackwizards has stated many foods have more than just sals in them, many foods also contain sals and amines or sals, amines and glutamates.

    You can purchase the book by going to the RPAH website (as above) and go to "Publications/Resources" and download the international order form if you live overseas.

    Kind Regards
    Marie